Landlord insurance in Utah, from someone who knows rentals

Renting out a property changes everything about how it needs to be insured. A regular home policy is written for a home you live in. A landlord policy is written for a home someone else lives in, and the difference shows up at claim time. I'm Zack McGonigle, an independent agent with Cottonwood Insurance, and I also study rental investing myself, including the Section 8 program, so I set landlord coverage up the way an owner would want it.

I respond within the hour during business hours, Mon to Fri, 9 to 6. No pressure and no spam, just a real conversation with a real person.

Landlord insurance

What I help with

Dwelling coverage

Priced on real rebuild cost for your rental, not its market value or an old landlord policy that has not been reviewed in years.

Quote a property

Landlord liability

Protection when a tenant or guest is injured on the property, with limits that reflect what you own beyond the rental itself.

Check my liability

Loss of rents

If a covered loss makes the unit unlivable, this replaces the rent while repairs happen, so one fire does not stop the property's income for months.

Add loss of rents
Why it matters

Who it is for, and what Utah throws at rentals

Anyone who owns a rental property in Utah: single-family rentals, condos, duplexes, basement apartments, and short-term rentals with the use disclosed and the policy built for it. If tenants live there and you do not, this is your page. Properties rented through housing voucher programs like Section 8 are welcome, and I understand how the program works from the landlord side.

Utah rentals face winter pipe bursts, snow and ice liability on walkways and stairs, and water damage from tenant appliances. If you rent near the mountains or in a college town, turnover and vacancy patterns matter too. One property or a growing portfolio, I can schedule multiple addresses under a structure that stays manageable as you add doors.

Client reviews

Rated 5.0 across 10 Google reviews

★★★★★

Zack helped me with my renters insurance and made the process so simple. A quick conversation with what felt like a family member helped me save money! I referred him to my mother and other friends as well because he was so helpful!

Jujuan Laverick

★★★★★

Zack was super helpful in walking me through my home and auto insurance options. He took the time to understand what I needed, helped me get the right coverage and found ways for me to save some money. The whole process was easy and stress free. Really appreciate his help and would definitely recommend reaching out to him!!

Kruttika Srinivasan

★★★★★

What a godsend! Zack helped me save $430 on my six month policy and was always quick to respond and answer any questions I had. Make your life easy and go to him for your insurance needs!

Trajan Morton

Read all reviews

Questions

Good questions, straight answers

Yes, and the difference matters. A standard home policy expects you to live in the home. Insuring a tenant-occupied home on the wrong policy can cause real problems with a claim.

Yes. Voucher program rentals are welcome, and steady long term tenancies are exactly what landlord coverage is built for.

No. Your policy covers your building and your liability. Your tenant's belongings are covered by their own renters policy, which is why many landlords require one.

In most cases yes. Tell me about each property in the quote form and I will structure the options for you.

Tell me, because vacancy changes how coverage applies. I would rather set it up right than have a claim surprise either of us.

Many landlords do. Rental properties add liability exposure, and an umbrella policy sits on top of it. Ask me and I will price both.

Contact

Let's talk

Pick Landlord on the quote form and I will build the rental version of the coverage for you, personally.