Holladay insurance for character homes

I'm Zack McGonigle, an independent insurance agent with Cottonwood Insurance serving Holladay and the east side. Established neighborhoods with older character homes need an agent who understands what those houses really are. I shop multiple carriers, compare your options thoughtfully, and actually pick up my phone.

Takes about 60 seconds. No pressure, no spam, just a real quote from a real person.

What I help with

Coverage for Holladay

Five areas, one point of contact for Holladay households. Tell me what you need and I'll shop the carriers to find your best fit.

Auto Insurance

Holladay driving is mostly local: Highland Drive, 4500 South, and I-215 into downtown or up toward the Cottonwood canyons. I'll compare rates across carriers, look for low-mileage and safe-driver discounts, and make sure multi-car households are bundled the right way.

Get an auto quote

Home Insurance

Mid-century ramblers, older colonials, and Olympus Cove homes with real character cost more to rebuild than most policies assume. I'll calculate what yours would actually cost to rebuild today, updates and finishes included, and close any gap I find.

Get a home quote

Commercial Insurance

For business owners who can't afford gaps. General liability, property, and commercial auto, built around how your business actually operates.

Get a business quote

Umbrella Insurance

Extra liability protection that kicks in when your auto or home policy limits run out. Surprisingly affordable, and a must if you have assets to protect.

Get an umbrella quote

Life Insurance

Simple, honest guidance on protecting your family's future. I'll walk you through term vs. permanent in plain English and find coverage that fits your budget.

Get a life quote

Bundle & Save

Have more than one policy? Bundling auto, home, and umbrella with the same carrier is usually the fastest way to cut your total premium.

Get a bundle quote
Why local matters

Older homes need smarter coverage

Replacement costs, updated systems, and mature lots. Here is what I watch for.

Character home rebuilds

Mid-century ramblers and older colonials cost far more to rebuild than their market price suggests. I'll run a real replacement-cost estimate so you're not underinsured.

Updates and systems

Older wiring, plumbing, and roofs change how carriers price you, and recent updates can earn meaningful discounts. I'll make sure your policy reflects the updates you've made.

Mature trees and lots

Big trees mean falling-limb claims and root damage. I'll check your other-structures and liability coverage against the actual property.

Earthquake consideration

East-side homes near the Wasatch Fault should at least price an earthquake endorsement. I'll give you the real number so you can decide.

FAQ

Holladay insurance questions

It can, mainly because of rebuild costs and older systems, but it is not automatic. Carriers look closely at roof age and material, the electrical panel, and the type of plumbing in the home. Updates like a new roof, rewiring, or replumbing earn credits that often offset the older-home pricing. I'll document the updates you have made and shop the carriers that price Holladay's character homes fairly.

Market value is what your house would sell for, and it includes the land, which does not burn down or blow away. Replacement cost is what it would take to rebuild the same house at today's labor and material prices. Insurance should be based on replacement cost only. For older Holladay homes with real craftsmanship, that number is often higher than owners expect, and I'll calculate it properly for your home and show you both figures.

Yes. I serve Millcreek, Cottonwood Heights, and Murray along with Holladay and the whole east side, including Olympus Cove and the neighborhoods along Holladay Boulevard. My office is in Cottonwood Heights, just a few minutes away, and I work with clients across all of Utah as well.

Near the Wasatch Fault, it is worth pricing seriously. Standard home policies exclude earthquake damage entirely, so without an endorsement or a standalone policy, a quake means paying for repairs yourself. Earthquake coverage carries a deductible set as a percentage of your home's insured value rather than a flat amount, which surprises people. I'll quote it, walk you through the deductible math, and give you the real numbers so you can decide with clear eyes.

Contact

Let's talk

Serving Holladay and Salt Lake County. When you call, you are talking to a local agent who knows the area, not a call center. Call, email, or start with the quote form. I actually pick up, and if I miss you, I'll call back the same day.

Zack McGonigle with his wife

Reach me directly

(385) 541-2801

zackm@cottonwoodins.com

Office: Cottonwood Heights, Utah
Serving all of Utah, plus clients across Oregon and Arizona.

Office hours: Monday-Friday, 9am-6pm.
After hours, my cell is always on: (714) 403-7130

Prefer to start online?

The 60-second quote form is the fastest way to get numbers in front of you. Fill it out anytime and I'll take it from there.

Get My Free Quote

Already a client? Leave a review and help your Holladay neighbors find coverage they can trust.

Proudly serving Holladay, Salt Lake County, and every county in Utah, plus clients in Oregon and Arizona.