Home insurance, repriced honestly before you renew

Home premiums have climbed hard the last few years, and most renewals arrive with a bigger number and no explanation. I'm Zack McGonigle, an independent insurance agent with Cottonwood Insurance. Before you just pay it, let me check your rebuild cost, your roof age pricing, and your options across carriers, and show you the comparison in plain English.

I respond within the hour during business hours, Mon to Fri, 9 to 6. No pressure and no spam, just a real conversation with a real person.

Home insurance

What I help with

Rebuild cost, checked

Your coverage should reflect what your home would cost to rebuild today. Too low is a claim disaster, too high is wasted premium. I calculate it properly.

Check my rebuild cost

Utah risks, priced right

Roof age, water damage, winter claims and liability all price differently here. I make sure your policy reflects your home as it actually is, not as a form guessed years ago.

Review my policy

Compared across carriers

One company's increase is not the whole market. I compare your home across the carriers I represent and show you the differences line by line.

Compare my options
Why it matters

Why your renewal jumped, and what to do about it

Rebuild costs, reinsurance prices and claim severity have all pushed home premiums up across the industry. Some of your increase is the market. Some of it may be your policy: an old roof surcharge that should have changed, discounts that fell off, coverage amounts drifting upward on autopilot.

A comparison separates the two. If the market moved and your current policy is still the best fit, I will tell you. If your policy is the problem, you will see exactly where, with other carriers' numbers beside it.

Client reviews

Rated 5.0 across 10 Google reviews

★★★★★

Zack helped me with my renters insurance and made the process so simple. A quick conversation with what felt like a family member helped me save money! I referred him to my mother and other friends as well because he was so helpful!

Jujuan Laverick

★★★★★

Zack was super helpful in walking me through my home and auto insurance options. He took the time to understand what I needed, helped me get the right coverage and found ways for me to save some money. The whole process was easy and stress free. Really appreciate his help and would definitely recommend reaching out to him!!

Kruttika Srinivasan

★★★★★

What a godsend! Zack helped me save $430 on my six month policy and was always quick to respond and answer any questions I had. Make your life easy and go to him for your insurance needs!

Trajan Morton

Read all reviews

Questions

Good questions, straight answers

Usually a mix of industry-wide rebuild costs and policy-specific factors like roof age and claims history. I will break your increase down into the parts you can and cannot control.

I match your current coverage as the starting point, then flag anything I would change and why, so you are comparing like with like before deciding.

Your address, the age of your roof, and your current policy if you have it handy. I pull the property details and do the rest.

Contact

Let's talk

Send me your address and I will build the comparison personally.