← Back to all issues

The Insurance Brief

Older Home? Your Insurance Gap Just Got Bigger

October 23, 2026 · Issue #8 · 3 min read

Hey, it is Zack. If your home has been standing for a few decades, this one is for you, because your house itself may be a bigger part of your insurance bill than you realize.

Rates have gone up for almost everyone in the last few years. But a new look at the numbers shows the increases have not landed evenly, and older homes have taken the harder hit.

What the new numbers say

NerdWallet's 2026 Home Insurance Rates Report looked at more than 840 million rate estimates. It found that home insurance premiums for a typical homeowner rose 24 percent from the first quarter of 2023 to the first quarter of 2026.

For a home built in 1984 with a homeowner who has good credit, that worked out to an average increase of about $496 a year.

Here is the part that caught my eye. That same 1984 home now costs 81.2 percent more to insure than a comparable newly built home, a gap of more than $1,000 a year. In early 2023, the gap was 59.2 percent. So in just three years, the penalty for an older home got a lot steeper.

The West saw smaller increases than some other regions, at 16.4 percent, compared with 25 percent in the Midwest. That is a small piece of good news for Utah, but it does not erase the age gap if your roof, wiring, or plumbing is aging along with the house.

What this means for you

Carriers are looking harder at the parts of a home that wear out and cause claims: the roof, the electrical system, the plumbing, and the heating system. An older home is not a bad home. Plenty of Utah homes built in the 1970s and 1980s are solid and well loved. The issue is that older systems can cost more to repair, and they can raise the odds of a water, fire, or weather claim.

That also means updates matter, but only if your carrier knows about them. If you have replaced a roof, updated electrical work, or replumbed part of the house and never told your insurance company, your policy may still be priced as if the old systems are in place.

There is one hopeful note in the same report: in 2026, insurers sought only modest rate increases, with the median requested change under 1 percent. After several hard years, that points to some stabilization. It is exactly why shopping and updating your file at renewal can pay off right now.

One quick tip

Make a short update list for your home before your next renewal. Write down the year of your roof, any electrical or plumbing updates, and any heating or water heater replacements, and keep photos or receipts if you have them. Then call your agent and ask a plain question: is all of this reflected in my policy, and should my home be re-rated? It takes a few minutes, and it makes sure you are not paying for risk you have already fixed.

Want a second set of eyes on your policy?

It takes about 60 seconds to start. I will shop the carriers and show you your options in plain English. You can also call me at (385) 541-2801.

Get My Free Quote

See you in the next issue.
Zack McGonigle
Independent Insurance Agent, Cottonwood Insurance · (385) 541-2801

← Back to all issues