← Back to all issues

The Insurance Brief

Utah Auto Rates Are Holding Steady. That Is Your Opening

October 16, 2026 · Issue #6 · 3 min read

Hey, it is Zack. Good news does not show up in insurance very often, so when it does, I want you to hear it from me.

This week, a Utah report made a simple point: while a lot of household costs are still climbing, auto insurance here is giving drivers a rare chance to compare and possibly save.

What is happening

KUTV reported this week that Utah auto insurance premiums have held mostly steady in 2026, even as gas prices have been on a steady climb. Some carriers in Utah are actually lowering their rates.

A Utah agent interviewed in that report explained the shift this way, in my words: many companies are in a stronger position right now, they are profitable, and they want to bring on new clients. He said he is seeing more rate decreases this year than in the last four or five years.

That matches the national picture, with an important twist. The Zebra puts the median annual auto premium in the United States at $2,079 in 2026, or about $173 a month, up from $2,016 in 2025. Its research also found that eleven states recorded lower median premiums this year, while most other states saw increases of less than $100.

In plain English: the country is not moving in one direction anymore. Your result depends a lot on where you live, which carrier you are with, and whether that carrier wants more business right now. Utah, according to that local report, has a competitive market with plenty of options for drivers.

What it means for you

If you have been with the same carrier for a few years and you just let each renewal roll over, this is the kind of market that can reward a fresh look. The carrier that was cheapest for you two years ago may not be the cheapest for you today, and the only way to know is to compare the same coverage side by side.

Please do not shop by cutting coverage first. Start with the limits and deductibles you have now, get quotes that match them, and then decide if you want to change anything. That keeps the comparison honest and keeps you from buying a lower price that quietly leaves you with less protection.

It also helps to shop before your renewal date, not after it. When you have a little time, you can ask questions, check the details, and make a calm choice. When you wait until the last day, you usually just pay the bill in front of you.

One quick tip

Pull out your declarations page before you ask for any quote. That one page lists your drivers, your vehicles, your limits, and your deductibles all in one place. Send that page with your request and you will get a faster, cleaner comparison, and you will spot anything outdated right away.

Want me to compare your auto coverage?

It takes about 60 seconds to start. I will shop the carriers, compare the same coverage side by side, and show you your options in plain English. You can also call me at (385) 541-2801.

Get My Free Quote

See you in the next issue.
Zack McGonigle
Independent Insurance Agent, Cottonwood Insurance · (385) 541-2801

← Back to all issues