← Back to all issues

The Insurance Brief

Raising Your Deductible to Save Money? Read This First

October 13, 2026 · Issue #5 · 3 min read

Hey, it is Zack. If your renewal made you wince this fall, you are not alone, and you are probably thinking about the same lever a lot of families are pulling right now: a higher deductible.

It can be a smart move. It can also leave you stuck paying for a repair out of pocket at the worst possible moment. The difference comes down to one simple question, and we will get to it below.

What is happening

New research from The Zebra, based on a survey of 1,500 vehicle owners and more than 32 million rates, puts the median annual auto premium in the U.S. at $2,079 in 2026, or about $173 a month. That is up from $2,016 in 2025.

When The Zebra asked what drivers would do if premiums rose another 10 percent, 45 percent said they would either reduce coverage or increase their deductible. Another 29 percent said they would consider cancelling or suspending coverage entirely.

Home insurance is showing the same pattern. A 2026 study from Rate Insurance found that policies with deductibles under $2,500 fell from 73.52 percent of policies in 2018 to 59.67 percent in 2025. In plain English: more of the risk is quietly shifting from the insurance company onto the family.

That shift makes sense when repair costs keep climbing. Insurify notes that auto maintenance and repair costs have risen 45 percent in the past five years. A higher deductible lowers your monthly bill, but it raises what a bad day costs you.

What it means for you

Here is the test I use with clients: could you write a check for that deductible tomorrow, without putting it on a credit card?

If the answer is yes, a higher deductible is often worth pricing out. You are trading a lower premium every month for a larger amount you would pay only if you file a claim, and over a few claim free years that trade can pay off.

If the answer is no, be careful. Saving, say, $15 or $20 a month is not a win if a $1,000 or $2,500 deductible means you cannot afford to get the car fixed or the roof patched after a loss. And please do not drop coverage you legally need, or that protects you from a loss you could not absorb, just to make the premium fit.

One quick tip

Before you change anything, price two versions side by side: your current deductible and one step higher. Then do the math: how many months of savings would it take to cover the extra amount you would owe after a claim? If the savings take four or five years to break even, it is probably not the deal it looks like. If they break even in a year or so, and you have the cash set aside, it might be.

While you are in there, check your home coverage amount too. That same Rate Insurance study found average replacement costs reached $478,000 in 2025. If your dwelling limit has not kept up with what it would actually cost to rebuild, a lower premium today will not help much after a big loss.

Want me to run the deductible math with you?

It takes about 60 seconds to start. I will shop the carriers, compare deductible options side by side, and show you the numbers in plain English. You can also call me at (385) 541-2801.

Get My Free Quote

See you in the next issue.
Zack McGonigle
Independent Insurance Agent, Cottonwood Insurance · (385) 541-2801

← Back to all issues