← Back to all issues

The Insurance Brief

Insurance Prices Are Cooling Off (Here's Your Window)

October 9, 2026 · Issue #4 · 3 min read

Hey, it's Zack. Quick question: when's the last time you actually shopped your insurance? Not the renewal notice you glanced at and paid, but a real side-by-side comparison. If your answer is "a few years ago," this issue is for you.

What happened

For three straight years, insurance went one direction: up. Home insurance rates rose about 24% between early 2023 and early 2026, according to NerdWallet's 2026 rates report. In June, the average homeowner with a mortgage paid a record $209 a month for property insurance, nearly 80% more than in 2020 (data from Intercontinental Exchange, reported by MarketWatch). Auto insurance had its own brutal run in 2022, 2023, and 2024.

That run looks like it's ending. The U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics reports its motor vehicle insurance price index was 5.1% lower this August than a year earlier. Insurify's October data shows the national average for full-coverage auto insurance held flat at $187 a month through August, basically unchanged all summer. On the home side, a Matic mid-year analysis found that 11.7% of homeowners who renewed in the first half of 2026 actually saw their premium go down, up from 7.4% last year. The average renewal increase fell to 10.6%, down from 19.4% in 2025.

Even better, carriers are coming back to the table. Matic found the average shopper had 27% more quotes available than a year ago, up 74% from the 2024 low point. In Texas, carriers have been filing rate decreases since July: auto filings reached 4.4 million policyholders, and home filings averaged a 4.3% decrease (per the Texas Department of Insurance, reported by Carrier Management).

What it means for you

Here's the part that matters. If you haven't shopped your policies in two or three years, you're probably still paying peak prices. Your carrier raised your rate when they needed to. They are not going to call you up and offer to lower it now that the market is loosening. The savings are out there, but you have to go get them.

And if you're in Utah, this matters even more. After the nonrenewal wave we talked about in the last issue, carriers are competing for good customers again. That makes this fall one of the best shopping windows we've had in years. Competition is the whole ballgame in insurance, and it's back.

One quick tip

Before your next renewal, get fresh quotes on your auto AND your home together. Bundling both with one carrier is still one of the biggest single discounts in insurance, and with roughly a quarter more quotes available than last year, comparison shopping actually pays off again. Pull your declarations page, spend ten minutes on it, and you might be surprised at what you find. Or skip the homework and send it to me. This is literally what I do all day.

Want a second set of eyes on your policy?

It takes about 60 seconds to start. I'll shop the carriers and show you your options in plain English.

Get My Free Quote

See you in the next issue.
Zack McGonigle
Independent Insurance Agent, Cottonwood Insurance · (385) 541-2801

← Back to all issues