Hey, it's Zack. I came across a stat last month that made me do a double take, and I haven't stopped thinking about it since. Utah just became the worst state in America for home insurance non-renewals. Yes, you read that right. Not California, not Florida. Utah.
New data from Weiss Ratings, reported by Insurance Business Magazine in September, shows 4.45% of Utah home policies were non-renewed. That is 1 in 22 homes. It is 8.4 times the rate from 2018 and more than double last year's rate. We jumped from 17th worst to 1st in a single year. California, the poster child for insurance headaches, is sitting in second at 2.93%.
The driver is wildfire risk. Carriers are redrawing their maps around fire exposure, and Utah's wildland-urban interface is under the microscope. The zones getting the most scrutiny: Washington County, the Wasatch foothills, and communities near national forest borders. In those areas, the question has shifted from "what's my price" to "will anyone insure me at all."
This is not happening in a vacuum. Utah home insurance rates rose 70.6% between 2019 and 2024, the second biggest jump in the country, per S&P Global data. Nationally, the average premium is on track to hit about $3,057 this year, up 46% since 2021. That is roughly $900 more a year than five years ago.
Here is what most people get wrong about non-renewals: it is almost never about you. You paid on time, you filed no claims, and you still got the letter. That is because carriers are managing risk at the map level now, not the customer level. If your home sits in a zip code they no longer like, the renewal does not come.
The real danger is letting coverage lapse while you figure it out. If your lender finds out you have no homeowner's policy, they will buy force-placed insurance for you. It costs a fortune, it protects them instead of you, and it gets added straight to your mortgage payment. Never let there be a gap.
If your non-renewal is wildfire-related, Utah's HB 48 law entitles you to the specific reason. Ask your carrier for it in writing. Is it the wildfire risk score, the roof age, proximity to a risk zone, or claims history? Knowing exactly why tells you what might be fixable, like documenting roof age or clearing defensible space, and it gives you real information to shop with. Start shopping the day that letter arrives. You usually get 30 to 60 days, and the carriers still hungry for Utah business have limited appetite. If you need a hand, the Utah Insurance Department's consumer line is 1-800-439-3805.
It takes about 60 seconds to start. As an independent agent I work with multiple carriers, so if one won't take your home, another often will. Prefer to talk it through? Call me at (385) 541-2801.
Get My Free QuoteSee you in the next issue.
Zack McGonigle
Independent Insurance Agent, Cottonwood Insurance · (385) 541-2801