Hey, it's Zack. Remember that nice stretch last year when car insurance finally started going down? Well, it's turning back around.
Insurify just put out their 2026 mid-year auto insurance report, and the numbers tell a clear story. After full-coverage rates fell about 6% in 2025, they're projected to end 2026 up about 1% year over year, with the national average landing around $2,242. Twenty-seven states have already seen rates go up in the first half of this year, and Insurify expects 32 states to be up by year end.
So what's driving it? In plain English, fixing cars has gotten expensive, and insurers are passing that along. Auto repair and maintenance costs are up 45% over the last five years, which is roughly double the rate of inflation. And here's one worth knowing: the 25% tariff on imported auto parts that took effect in April 2025 is still working its way into repair bills, and analysts expect it to push full-coverage premiums up another 4 to 7% as those costs land on insurers and get passed to drivers. Tariffs take 12 to 18 months to fully show up in your premium, so more of that is still coming.
One more thing the data shows: the market is splitting in two. Clean-record drivers are holding steady or even seeing a little relief, while drivers with accidents, tickets, or DUIs are seeing some of the biggest increases. Which side you're on matters more than ever.
The good news is Utah is still one of the more affordable states. Full-coverage here averages about $134 a month, compared to $182 nationally. But our growth along the Wasatch Front means more cars on I-15, more collisions, and carriers gradually nudging rates up. Utah's minimum liability limits also got raised to 30/65/25 at the start of last year, so policies here carry a little more coverage, and a little more cost, than before.
The bottom line: if your renewal notice looks higher and nothing changed on your end, that's this trend showing up at your door.
When a renewal comes in higher, most people just sigh and pay it. Don't. As an independent agent, I shop multiple carriers every day, and one carrier's 8% increase is another carrier's flat renewal. The single easiest win is bundling: putting your home and auto with the same carrier typically saves 10 to 25%, which can be hundreds a year. Send me your declarations page, I'll do the comparison for free, and I'll tell you straight if you're already in a good spot.
It takes about 60 seconds to start. I'll shop the carriers and show you your options in plain English. Prefer to talk it through? Call me at (385) 541-2801.
Get My Free QuoteSee you in the next issue.
Zack McGonigle
Independent Insurance Agent, Cottonwood Insurance · (385) 541-2801