← Back to all issues

The Car Enthusiast Brief

What Your Classic Is Actually Worth Right Now

October 8, 2026 · Issue #2 · 3 min read

Hey, it's Zack. Welcome back to The Car Enthusiast Brief.

If you only read the auction headlines this year, you'd think every old car on the planet is printing money. The truth is more interesting, and it matters for your insurance.

The headline: a $42.9 million headline and a market split in two

At Gooding Christie's Pebble Beach auction during Monterey Car Week, the 1964 Shelby Cobra Daytona Coupe, chassis CSX2300, hammered at $39 million and finished at $42.9 million with buyer's premium. That's the most expensive American car ever sold at public auction, beating the previous record, a 1935 Duesenberg at $22 million, by almost double. Monterey's total sales set a record, too, clearing $750 million for the week.

But look one level deeper and the story flips. According to CLASSIC.COM's data for the first half of 2026, the average auction sale price climbed 25 percent to $75,173, while the median sale price barely budged, from $25,550 to $26,500, a gain of less than 4 percent. Translation: a handful of million-dollar unicorns is dragging the average skyward while the car you and I would actually buy is treading water. Everyday classics from the middle decades are the softest part of the market right now.

And the hot end is not just prewar museum pieces. At Broad Arrow's Audrain Auction this week, a 1970 Dodge Coronet R/T with a 426 Hemi sold for $207,200 against a $150,000 to $200,000 estimate, and a 1969 Pontiac GTO convertible hit $128,800, also beating its estimate. Buyers are picky, but they are paying up for the right cars.

What this means for your coverage

Here's the insurance part, and it's simple. Most collector policies are written on an agreed-value basis: you and the insurer agree on the car's value up front, and a total loss pays that number. That number does not update itself when the market moves.

If you set your agreed value during the hot market a year or two ago and your segment has cooled since, you may be paying premium on a value the market no longer supports. And if you bought in one of the segments that's been climbing, like the right Mopars and muscle cars, you may be underinsured and leaving real money on the table if the worst happens. Either way, the number on your policy deserves a fresh look.

One quick tip

Before your next renewal, pull three comparable recent sales of your exact car (CLASSIC.COM and Hagerty's valuation tools make this easy) and ask your agent to true up the agreed value. Many collector policies let you revise it mid-term, so you don't have to wait for renewal to fix it. Overinsured means overpaying. Underinsured means a short check when you need it most.

Not sure your classic's value is right on your policy?

It takes about 60 seconds to start. I'll look at what you've got and tell you straight whether your coverage matches your car.

Get My Free Quote

Not subscribed yet? Join The Car Enthusiast Brief here.

See you in the next issue.
Zack McGonigle
Independent Insurance Agent, Cottonwood Insurance · (385) 541-2801

← Back to all issues