← Back to newsletters

The Business Owner's Brief

Commercial Property Rates Just Fell the Hardest in a Decade

October 14, 2026 · Issue #2 · 3 min read

Hey, it's Zack. Welcome back to The Business Owner's Brief.

If your commercial property renewal has felt painful for years, this week brings genuinely good news, plus a catch worth understanding. Let's walk through it in plain English.

Property rates are dropping, and competition is back

On October 1, Willis, a WTW business, released the fall 2026 edition of its Insurance Marketplace Realities report, covering more than thirty lines of commercial insurance in North America.

Here is the headline: large and complex property rates fell an average of 14.5 percent in the second quarter of 2026, compared with 8.4 percent a year earlier, as competition among insurers intensified. Shared and layered programs, meaning placements with five or more carriers, saw even bigger average declines of 23.41 percent.

Willis says the market has moved away from the depths of the hard market that ran from 2018 through 2024, back toward pricing last seen in 2019. In plain terms, carriers are competing for property business again.

Now, the honest caveat. Those averages are for large and complex programs, so they are not a promise that every small shop in Utah will see the same drop. Your building, your industry, and your claims history still matter a lot.

What it means for you

The same report was clear that not every line is softening. Auto liability and umbrella or excess lines for high hazard risks remain under pressure, and high hazard general liability does too. Willis also noted that global insured catastrophe losses reached 107 billion dollars in 2025, the sixth straight year above 100 billion, even though the first half of 2026 was calmer.

So do not shop your whole program expecting one simple story. Property is where the leverage is shifting to you right now. Liability and auto may still need a careful, carrier by carrier fight.

If your property renewal comes back flat, or only down a little, it is worth asking a simple question: did anyone actually compete for this? A second quote does not commit you to anything. It just tells you whether your current price reflects this new market, or last year's market.

Quick tip: fix your replacement cost before you shop

A lower rate does not help if the limit underneath it is wrong. Property limits should be set at replacement cost, and they should be revisited whenever your business hires, moves, buys equipment, or starts working in another state.

Take fifteen minutes this week and update a simple list: equipment, inventory, any buildout you paid for, and anything bought since your last renewal. If a fire happened tomorrow, that list is what you would want replaced. Bring that number to the quote, and your savings will be real, not just a cheaper price on too little coverage.

Want me to shop your commercial coverage?

Start on my commercial quote page. It covers general liability, commercial property, commercial auto, and workers comp in one in depth intake, so I can shop it properly. Prefer to talk first? Call me at (385) 541-2801.

Start a Commercial Quote

See you next Wednesday.
Zack McGonigle
Independent Insurance Agent, Cottonwood Insurance · (385) 541-2801

P.S. Know a business owner who would like this? Forward it to them. They can subscribe free right here: The Business Owner's Brief signup.

← Back to newsletters